top of page

How to Match Lab-Grown Diamonds for Stud Earrings

6 days ago
10 min read

By RAGAZZA DIAMOND


Two round diamonds can both weigh 1.00 carat and have nearly the same face-up diameter, yet look different side by side. One may appear more open at the centre, while the other gives smaller flashes as it moves. A pair of studs will catch the light at different moments on each ear, but the stones should have a similar size, colour and pattern of light and dark when you look at them under the same conditions.


When we match a pair of diamond studs, we start with the weight and measurements of each centre stone, compare their proportions, then inspect the diamonds side by side. This quickly narrows the shortlist and explains why two beautiful diamonds can make an uneven pair.



Contents




Carat weight and measurements


Match the carat weight of each stone


For round studs, our first requirement is that the weight recorded for each centre stone on its report or supplier record matches. If the target is 1.00 carat per ear, we select two 1.00-carat stones. A 0.99-carat stone and a 1.01-carat stone add up to 2.00 carats, but fall outside this matching standard. When shopping, distinguish between 2 carats total weight and 1 carat per ear.


Compare minimum diameter, maximum diameter and total depth


A round diamond's measurements are usually listed as minimum diameter–maximum diameter × total depth in millimetres. Compare both diameters and the difference between them, then check the depth. Two stones with similar average diameters can still differ in roundness. View them face-up together to see whether their outlines are equally full.


The left diagram shows the minimum and maximum diameters. The right shows total depth from the table to the culet.

Figure 1. The left diagram shows the minimum and maximum diameters. The right shows total depth from the table to the culet. (Illustration.)




Table size and total depth


The table is the flat facet at the centre of the diamond. A round diamond's table percentage and total depth percentage are measured against its average girdle diameter. In the example below, 3.96 mm is the measured depth and 61.4% expresses that depth relative to the diameter.


At the same average diameter of 6.45 mm, a 54% table is about 3.48 mm wide and a 60% table is about 3.87 mm wide. The difference is about 0.39 mm. Even when their outlines are the same size, the table and outer facets can occupy different proportions of the face-up view. Put the stones side by side and the difference may be visible. To judge which gives more brightness or fire, consider the crown and pavilion together and compare the stones under the same light.


At the same outside diameter, the left table is 54% and the right table is 60%. The outer facets occupy different proportions of the face-up view.

Figure 2. At the same outside diameter, the left table is 54% and the right table is 60%. The outer facets occupy different proportions of the face-up view. (Illustration.)


These diamonds have the same girdle diameter. The deeper pavilion on the right gives that stone a greater total depth.

Figure 3. These diamonds have the same girdle diameter. The deeper pavilion on the right gives that stone a greater total depth. (Illustration.)


Stone

Weight

Measurements (mm)

Table

Depth

Reference A

1.00 ct

6.43–6.46 × 3.96

54%

61.4%

Candidate B

1.00 ct

6.42–6.47 × 3.98

60%

61.8%

Candidate C

1.00 ct

6.44–6.46 × 3.97

55%

61.6%

Hypothetical measurements to illustrate the order of comparison.


To find a match for A, start by comparing it with C because their table percentages are closer. Once the table and depth percentages are close, check the crown, pavilion and actual light performance. These two figures help decide which candidate to examine first.


Use DAII™ to shortlist round diamonds


For round diamonds, we can also use RAGAZZA's DAII™ Diamond Quality Index. Stones with close overall scores can be grouped for comparison, then checked for proportions and appearance. Similar overall scores can come from different combinations of proportions, so the final check is to view the stones together as they move.




Brightness, scintillation and fire


Place the stones table-up on the same neutral grey or white tray, at matching angles. Start under evenly diffused light to compare the outlines, colour and overall brightness. Then tilt both slowly forward and back and from side to side. Swap their positions and repeat. If the darker stone brightens after the swap, check the direction of the light or whether your hand was casting a shadow.


Colour, clarity and cut grades are useful for screening. Once the stones are side by side, check whether one looks warmer or greyer, or whether inclusions in one are easier to see with the unaided eye.


Compare the diamonds side by side on one tray, then swap positions. The coloured dot follows the same stone.

Figure 4. Compare the diamonds side by side on one tray, then swap positions. The coloured dot follows the same stone. (Illustration.)


Compare three aspects of light performance


Brightness Look at the face-up return of white light under diffuse lighting. One diamond may look evenly bright while the other often looks bright mainly at the edge.


Scintillation and contrast Tilt both stones together. Watch where the dark areas move, how large the flashes are, and when they appear or disappear. Two diamonds can look similar when still and quite different when they move.


Fire Compare coloured flashes under a more concentrated light source, keeping the angles and distance consistent. Then check overall brightness again in ordinary light.


The left drawing shows broader flashes, the centre shows finer flashes, and the coloured flashes on the right illustrate fire.

Figure 5. The left drawing shows broader flashes, the centre shows finer flashes, and the coloured flashes on the right illustrate fire. (Illustration.)


When ordering online, ask for one video showing both diamonds face-up, tilted together and then swapped left to right. Separate videos can differ in lighting and exposure, making brightness and colour harder to compare.




Fancy shapes and how they sit on the ear


Start with the length, width and depth of each fancy-shape diamond, then calculate the length-to-width ratio. Compare both the actual size and the outline. Two pear shapes can each measure 8.00 × 5.00 mm and have a ratio of 1.60, yet one can narrow earlier towards the point while the other carries more width in its shoulders.


The two pear shapes share the same length and width. The left has fuller shoulders and the right narrows sooner towards the point.

Figure 6. The two pear shapes share the same length and width. The left has fuller shoulders and the right narrows sooner towards the point. (Illustration.)


What to compare on each shape


Oval Align the long axes, then compare the rounded ends and the sides. One can have flatter sides and the other a fuller outline even when their dimensions are similar.


Pear and marquise Align the point and rounded end of each pear. Check that the point follows the long axis and note where the shoulders narrow. On marquise diamonds, check whether both tips sit on the same axis and whether the sides curve evenly.


Cushion and emerald cut Compare how much the corners are rounded or clipped, the curve of the sides and the overall dimensions. With similar length-to-width ratios, a difference at the corners can be more noticeable than a difference in weight.


Lay out the pair as it will be worn


If the pears are intended to angle outwards, mark the left and right ears on the tray. Compare the direction of the tips, the angles and the outlines. Placing both stones in the same direction helps compare their individual outlines. For a mirrored design, set them out as they will be worn, both when matching the stones and when checking the trial settings.


On the left both diamonds tilt in the same direction. On the right they mirror each other, with their tips pointing outwards.

Figure 7. On the left both diamonds tilt in the same direction. On the right they mirror each other, with their tips pointing outwards. (Illustration.)




Contrast and windowing in fancy shapes


See where the bow tie appears and when it fades


View ovals, pears and marquises face-up to compare the position, width and depth of the bow-tie pattern, then tilt both stones sideways and forward and back. Some contrast adds definition. Watch whether both stones brighten at similar angles. Pay particular attention when one brightens with a slight tilt while the other stays dark through several positions.


Each row shows one diamond at three successive angles. The bow tie fades across the top row and stays darker across the bottom row.

Figure 8. Each row shows one diamond at three successive angles. The bow tie fades across the top row and stays darker across the bottom row. (Illustration.)


Compare the size and distribution of flashes


Some fancy shapes produce broad flashes. Others show finer flashes with a crushed-ice appearance. Compare the size of the flashes and whether they appear mainly in the centre or at the ends. Even when both stones have fine flashes, a pair can look uneven in motion if those flashes cluster at the ends on one stone and spread across the other.


The left drawing shows broader areas of light and dark. The right shows finer flashes.

Figure 9. The left drawing shows broader areas of light and dark. The right shows finer flashes. (Illustration.)


Distinguish a dark step from a window


In an emerald cut or another step cut, look at the widths of the rows of facets and how the bands of light move towards the centre. A dark step still shows the boundaries of the reflecting facet. With a window, you can see the background through the stone. Tilt the two stones through the same angles to compare when the window appears, how much of the stone it covers and whether the centre brightens again as the stones return face-up.


The left stone shows alternating light and dark steps. The line on the tray can be seen through the centre of the stone on the right.

Figure 10. The left stone shows alternating light and dark steps. The line on the tray can be seen through the centre of the stone on the right. (Illustration.)




Hue, tone and saturation in coloured diamonds


Read the complete colour name and intensity on the reports for fancy-colour lab-grown diamonds. Two stones can both be Fancy Intense, while one is Fancy Intense Pink and the other Fancy Intense Purplish Pink. The second description identifies a purple modifier. Compare the stones side by side even when the full colour descriptions match.


Compare the direction of the hue


Start with the dominant hue and then look for modifiers. With pink diamonds, one may lean purple or orange, or one may have a greyer or browner cast. Under neutral lighting, first shortlist stones that look close in hue, then compare how light, dark or vivid they appear.


Three pink hues, from left to right: neutral pink, purplish pink and orangy pink.

Figure 11. Three pink hues, from left to right: neutral pink, purplish pink and orangy pink. (Illustration.)


Compare tone and saturation separately


Tone is how light or dark a colour appears. Saturation is how vivid or muted it looks. A darker pink may also be more saturated, but the two can vary independently. First look for a light–dark difference, then see whether one colour looks more vivid or greyer. A tonal difference can stand out when the two studs are separated by the width of the face.


On the left the swatches differ in tone. On the right their tone is closer and one colour is more saturated.

Figure 12. On the left the swatches differ in tone. On the right their tone is closer and one colour is more saturated. (Illustration.)


If similarly graded diamonds look clearly different in tone or saturation, compare other candidates. Stones whose colour descriptions differ but look close can stay on the shortlist for another comparison after swapping positions and changing the lighting.




Colour distribution and the setting


Check where colour shows across the face


Check the centre, ends and edges with the stones face-up. Two pink diamonds can look similar overall, while one is evenly coloured and the other is richer at the ends or pale in the centre. Swap them at the same face-up angle, then tilt them together slightly. If the pale area follows the same stone, compare its face-up colour and cut pattern more closely.


Colour is more even on the left and concentrated at the ends on the right, leaving a paler centre.

Figure 13. Colour is more even on the left and concentrated at the ends on the right, leaving a paler centre. (Illustration.)


Compare under neutral light, then in warmer light and against the metal


Begin with neutral light and a white or light-grey tray. Compare both stones once more under warmer indoor light or indirect daylight. Separate videos can vary in exposure and white balance. To show a customer the pair, film both together against the same background with exposure and white balance fixed.


Once the loose stones match in colour, trial-fit them in identical settings of the same metal and recheck colour and contrast. This matters especially when yellow or rose gold surrounds much of the stone. If the difference becomes more obvious under other conditions, try another candidate, then check it again on the neutral tray.


The same two pink colours are shown against white metal on the left and rose gold on the right. Compare both stones against the same metal.

Figure 14. The same two pink colours are shown against white metal on the left and rose gold on the right. Compare both stones against the same metal. (Illustration.)


We first keep candidates that are close in hue, tone, saturation and colour distribution, then judge how well their outlines and light performance work together. For studs, the result on both ears usually matters more than the strength of colour in either stone on its own.




Final setting checks and replacement studs


Check before and after setting


Trial-fit the matched diamonds in identical settings. Compare the height of the stones, the positions of the prongs, how much of each diamond is visible and its orientation. After setting, check the pair from the front and at an angle, then look from a normal conversation distance. Well-matched stones can still look uneven if one sits higher or has more of its girdle hidden by the prongs.


The diamonds on the left are set at the same height. One on the right sits higher, a difference you can check from the side.

Figure 15. The diamonds on the left are set at the same height. One on the right sits higher, a difference you can check from the side. (Illustration.)


Replace a lost stud


If you lose one stud, bring the remaining earring and its original grading report or purchase record if you have it. Shortlist candidates by the original stone's weight and measurements, then use the remaining stud to compare colour and light performance. If you have only the mounted stone and no report, measure the visible face, check the order records and estimate the range to search. Keep any estimated weight separate from a confirmed weight.


Record how you matched the pair


Record both stones' individual references, carat weights and dimensions on the work order, then add a brief observation. For example, note that the pear for the right ear points outwards and both bow ties fade at a slight tilt, or that the pink diamonds still match under both neutral and warm lighting. Those notes explain the original decision if a stone later needs replacement.


A well-matched pair stands up to one simple check. Put both diamonds under the same light, tilt them together, then swap their positions and look again. When the two appear close in size, colour and the way they flash, the pair is ready.


 
 
bottom of page